Judges Challenge CCJ President’s Leadership

A major investigation published by Trinidad’s Sunday Express is raising concerns about whether the Caribbean Court of Justice is facing its most serious internal crisis yet. The report reveals that five of the CCJ’s six sitting judges allegedly challenged the leadership of CCJ President Justice Winston Anderson, accusing him of an authoritarian management style, panel manipulation and attempts to influence judicial decision-making. According to the newspaper, some of the concerns extended to the handling of high-profile matters before the court, including cases originating from Belize that were referenced in the internal exchanges among judges. The allegations surfaced through leaked correspondence that began with a dispute over a proposed judicial dress code but reportedly evolved into broader complaints about the court’s governance and independence. One judge reportedly warned of a growing “toxic” environment, while another described what he saw as anti-democratic decision-making within the institution. In response, the CCJ has defended its integrity and independence, stating that allegations presented without full context could be misunderstood and reaffirming its commitment to the principles of judicial conduct. As questions continue to mount across the region, observers are now asking, is the Caribbean Court of Justice in turmoil?

 

Attention readers: This online newscast is a direct transcript of our evening television broadcast. When speakers use Kriol, we have carefully rendered their words using a standard spelling system.

Watch the full newscast here: