Who Has the Final Say? HPV Debate Heats Up Behind Closed Doors

Tonight, a growing national debate over the HPV vaccine is putting parents, schools, and the state on a collision course. The Catholic Diocese is pushing back against the rollout on its school compounds, and while church leaders and health officials are keeping talks behind closed doors, the issue is spilling into the public. One church representative is now speaking up, arguing this isn’t about rejecting vaccines, but about who gets the final say. Church Senator Louis Wade says that responsibility belongs to parents, not schools. So, as the rollout continues, the big question remains, who decides what’s best for Belize’s children? News Five’s Shane Williams has more.

 

Shane Williams, Reporting

The controversy surrounding the HPV vaccine rollout in Belizean schools continues to gain national attention. With the Diocese pushing back, parents are sounding off, flooding social media with strong opinions on both sides of the vaccine debate. Many parents have voiced support for the vaccine, citing its role in preventing cervical cancer and other HPV-related illnesses. Others, however, side with the Diocese, arguing that schools shouldn’t be the main channel for distributing vaccines. The Ministry of Health and Wellness has repeatedly stated that the HPV vaccination program is voluntary and requires parental consent before any child receives the vaccine. Both the ministry and the Catholic Diocese turned down interview requests today, saying they prefer to continue talks behind closed doors. But Church Senator Louis Wade is publicly supporting the Diocese’s position. Wade says the objection is not rooted in anti-vaccine sentiment but instead centers on the need for informed consent.

 

Louis Wade, Church Senator

“So we are talking about the fact that the school has children who are under the authority of parents. So the Ministry of Health was in the public domain two weeks ago explaining why contraceptives needed not be over the counter, that the, they preferred that the individual goes into the medical professional to explain the contraceptives, et cetera. Why not the same for vaccines? Why in two weeks’ time the Ministry of Health has reversed the position?”

 

Wade argues that decisions involving vaccinations should be handled directly between healthcare authorities and parents, rather than schools serving as the mechanism for dissemination.

 

Louis Wade

“The Roman Catholic Church did the right thing by putting the parent. It’s not just a issue of consent, it is an issue of informed consent. So the Ministry of Health say, “Oh, but there is a paper that they take home that the parent tick yes or no.” It’s not enough for the school because there are a few parents out there that might say, “Oh well teacher send it.” Teacher is a authority figure. What we don’t want is consent because the school sent it. What we want is it’s consent from the parent because the parent is informed of the medical implications of this particular vaccination.”

 

With talks set to begin, the battle over HPV vaccines in schools is far from over and tensions aren’t easing anytime soon. But the Church Senator wished to make one point emphatically clear.

 

Louis Wade

“The church is not anti-vax. I can say that categorically because I read the information that’s put forward by the Roman Catholic Church on that specific vaccination.”

 

We will continue seek clarification from the Ministry of Health and Wellness on the status of the program in the more than two hundred primary schools not managed by the Catholic Diocese. Shane Williams for News Five.

 

Attention readers: This online newscast is a direct transcript of our evening television broadcast. When speakers use Kriol, we have carefully rendered their words using a standard spelling system.

 

Watch the full newscast here: